Essay on ucta and utccr

When Majid tried to re-negotiate the commission RTA refused.

Essay on ucta and utccr

Try out our Premium Member services: Free for one month and pay only if you like it. The subject of 'Unfair Terms In Contract' has attained grave importance in recent times not only in relation to consumer contracts but also in regard to other contracts. Inthe rd Report of the Law Commission was submitted and it was suggested that a single section sec.

That section, however, did not contain any general provision to deal with unfairness. In view of these developments in other countries, the Law Commission has taken up a detailed study of the subject suo motu. The Commission has referred to the statutes and Law Commission Reports of various countries in relation to unfair terms.

Unfair terms of contract law will not affect foreign investment: At the outset, we would like to refer to an argument that introduction of a law on 'unfair terms' may prejudicially affect foreign investment in India.

In this context, we may point out that the South African Law Commission has strongly refuted such an argument and stated that when such 'unfair terms' laws exist in several countries including UK, USA, Australia, New Zealand, Canada etc.

We are of the same opinion so far as India is concerned see our introductory chapter. Our business and commerce will be put to serious disadvantage if we do not have a law regulating unfair terms of contract. We have discussed in detail the existing provisions as regards voidable and void contracts under the Indian Contract Act, as well as non-enforcement of contracts where there is unfairness or hardship, as contained in the Specific Relief Act We have proposed that the provisions of these two statutes need not be disturbed.

We, however, propose, in addition, separate set of general provisions to deal with unfair terms of contracts. In view of the need to protect consumers and particularly to grant protection from the disadvantages of extensive introduction of standard terms of contracts which are one-sided, it has become necessary to evolve general principles regulating unfairness in contracts.

It is in this area that there are new legislations in other countries.

Get Group Discount

These new laws on unfairness elsewhere contain several important provisions intended to protect the weaker party against the stronger. Further, those statutes also contain a long list of guidelines to adjudge unfairness.

The UK Bill of annexed to the Report of the Law 4 Commission of UK and Scotland is perhaps the longest of any such statutes and it divides the discussion of unfairness in relation to consumer contracts, small businesses and other big businesses. That Bill contains a large number of schedules which deal with 'do's' and 'don'ts'.

Therefore, it has become necessary to provide additional provisions in India for redressal against unfair terms of contracts, apart from the existing provisions contained in the Indian Contract Act and Specific Relief Act.

While a law to deal with unfairness in contracts is necessary, the more important aspect is the division of unfairness into 'procedural' and 'substantive' unfairness. Such a division has not been done in any country so far, but there are several articles by jurists that such a division is necessary.

They point out that the laws in several countries have created a lot of confusion because they are a 'mish-mash' of procedural and substantive unfairness. We agree that such a division is absolutely necessary.

With that in view, we have examined the statutes of various countries and for our convenience and for purposes of our research, we have segregated the provisions in those countries into 'procedural' and 'substantive' ones with a view to have separate focus on those two aspects.

In this Report and the Bill annexed to this Report, we have, therefore, defined 'procedural unfairness' and 'substantive unfairness' separately and have also provided separate guidelines for each of them.

We shall briefly refer to these proposals. General 'procedural' unfairness and guidelines thereto: A contract or a term thereof is procedurally unfair if it has resulted in an unjust advantage or unjust disadvantage to one party on account of the conduct of the other party or the manner in which or the circumstances under which the contract has been entered into or the term thereof has been arrived at by the parties see sec.

We have provided separate statutory guidelines in sec.

Essay on ucta and utccr

We have likewise introduced a provision in sec. In addition, we have referred to three specific situations in sections 91011 of the proposed Bill where "substantive" unfairness has to be presumed. So far as exclusion of liability for breach of contract is concerned, we have added the words "without adequate justification" in the light of similar provisions abroad.

These three sections 910 and 11 deal with specific types of "substantive" unfairness, in addition to the general provision of 'substantive' unfairness in sec.The Unfair Terms in Consumer Contract Regulations is an upgrade of an earlier law of the same title that was passed by the United Kingdom Fair Use Policy; Help Centre; Notifications.

The UCTA itself, unlike the UTCCR, does not essay a specific unfairness test, but nevertheless provides for fairness standards through the so-called. The Unfair Contract Terms Act regulates clauses that exclude or limit terms implied by the common law or statute.

See the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Directive 93/13/EEC and UTCCR ; e.g. Bankway Properties Ltd v Pensfold-Dunsford [] An Essay in Perspective" () 40 Yale Law Journal ; AT von Mehren.

In this essay, the author considers two diverging ideas regarding statutory controls on unfair contract terms. Section 1 will address the idea that statutory controls on unfair contract terms foster genuine freedom of contract. However, despite the UCTA and UTCCR being aimed at protecting consumers there are also statutory.

Then after fully discussing this with reference to relevant case law, apply UCTA and UTCCR. Poor answers to this question Failed to use the relevant cases to support the arguments on incorporation, some failing to consider the common law rules at all. Ucta Law Essay. Topics: Contract C.

English Law of Contract

THE UNFAIR CONTRACT TERMS ACT The basic purpose of UCTA is to restrict the extent to which liability in a contract can be excluded for breach of contract and negligence, largely by reference to a reasonableness requirement, but in some cases by a specific prohibition.

Essay on pluralism and good governance. You have to pay to view full document. UTCCR in a nutshell.

Essay on ucta and utccr

You might begin by questioning what is the need for this legislation if we already have UCTA? Well the answer lies in that the regulations were an EU directive and thus were not an active choice for the judiciary to make when deciding to.

Mindy ChenWishart | University of Oxford -